Keyword Search Site Web    Yahoo!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
|
 
 
 
Hometown Recipes Community Calendar Tails & Paws Weddings Faith & Values 
 
 
The Public Salary Project: Why publish them? Because it's your money
 



 

For the past year, this newspaper has gathered salary information of local government employees from around this region. And, in today’s edition, we begin the first of a three-day series about this data and this issue.

The bulk of this tedious work, however, is evidenced at our two Web sites – TriCities.com and SWVAToday.com – with a searchable, online database that includes salaries from 65 towns, cities, counties and school systems in Southwest Virginia and Northeast Tennessee.

Just go to one of the Web sites and punch in keyword "salaries." The names, positions and salaries of more than 17,000 local government workers are included in this database.

WHY DID we do this?

Because it’s your money, and you have the right to know how it’s being spent. Salaries make up anywhere from one quarter to one half of the local government budgets you fund.

Many of you taxpayers will find this information interesting and be gratified that your regional newspaper is performing its watchdog role and making this information available to you. Many of the employees who are listed in this database will be angry, however: They will contend that this is nobody’s business and that this is an invasion of their privacy.

Those employees are wrong – not just philosophically but legally.

This is public information required to be disclosed under the freedom of information laws in the state of Tennessee and the commonwealth of Virginia.

NO ONE’S privacy has been invaded: No personal information is disclosed, only name, rank and serial number – or in this case, salary number.

It took a year for us to get this information from every jurisdiction we knew existed in this two-state region. (If we’ve missed any, let us know.)

Several local jurisdictions complied with the public records laws immediately. Among the shining examples: the tiny hamlet of Glade Spring, Va.

Several others thumbed their nose at state law for months and had to be threatened with lawsuits.

THESE WERE not idle threats. Our attorneys were waiting in the wings to sue jurisdictions that failed to turn over these public records. And had we sued, we also would have tried to recoup our attorney fees.

To this day, the city of Johnson City, Tenn., has not fully complied with our FOIA request because it never provided us with first names, only initials. It even took Johnson City four months to provide us with the salaries, and even then, the city demanded in exchange that we share with it the data from the other jurisdictions.

We refused and kindly informed Johnson City that if it wanted the data, it could file FOIAs with the other 64 agencies, like we did.

The Bristol Herald Courier is not the first newspaper to publish local government salaries and will not be the last. As more and more news consumers migrate to the Web, you will see more and more databases published online. (We don’t have the space to publish 17,374 salaries in the newspaper.)

AS I WROTE earlier in this column, this project is not unprecedented. I personally did a similar project last year at another Virginia newspaper. I knew what to expect: threats of lawsuits, allegations that we had invaded people’s privacy, name-calling. And I expect similar backlash from some local government employees in this region.

But the fact is when you go to work for an agency funded by taxpayers, you forfeit disclosure of your name, position and salary. Period.

The law says so, and for obvious reasons: It’s the public’s money.

By putting this information online and doing it in a searchable database, we are allowing readers with Internet access to make salary comparisons across jurisdictional lines, and to check every salary in their hometown or county to see where their tax dollars are going.

WE ARE NOT making any editorial statements about government workers being overpaid or underpaid. We simply are giving you the information, along with articles and graphics that further illustrate the data.

Some of the employees listed in this database will demand to know the salaries of the journalists employed by this newspaper. Fair is fair, they will say. That demand is specious, however, for we are not paid by taxpayers, but by a private-sector company.

Some local government workers upset at the disclosure of their salaries might even compare this project with what The Roanoke Times did earlier this year when it posted on its Web site the Virginia State Police database on residents who have concealed weapons permits.

The comparison is not apt. First off, that database was posted with raw data, including the home addresses of judges and police officers and every other citizen with a permit. Roanoke, an otherwise fine newspaper, had to remove that database immediately because the decision to post it online was made unilaterally by one uninformed employee.

CONVERSELY, WE created the database ourselves using only public information. We even deleted salaries under $10,000 although many jurisdictions provided such information; we deleted it because the commonwealth of Virginia requires only salaries of $10,000 or more to be disclosed. We carried over that standard to the state of Tennessee.

Our intent is not to embarrass local government workers, only to inform you where your tax dollars are going. You can judge for yourselves whether you’re getting your money’s worth.

J. Todd Foster is managing editor of the Bristol Herald Courier and can be reached at (276) 645-2513 or jfoster@bristolnews.com

 
Reader Reaction:
 
Posted January 30, 2008 @ 03:39 PM by Anonymous
Why has Elizabethton's not been posted?
 
Posted January 27, 2008 @ 09:18 PM by washcoresident
While the media has the legal right to access this information, it should also have the tact and forethought to not list entire names with salaries. Public record is one thing, stirring jealousy and envy in schools and public offices is another. There's another reason not to purchase a newspaper or watch the local news!
 
Posted January 23, 2008 @ 09:12 PM by Andy
How about we find out just how much you all are making. It isnt any of your business and you all lost alot of viewers for doing this. You should go to the courthouse like everyone else. It is wrong to post our infomation on a website.
 
Posted January 22, 2008 @ 11:40 AM by why be embrassed
I'm so sick and tried of hearing I put my life on the line everyday and I'm underpaid and overworked.If so quit find another job Its that simple. You knew the pay scale when you started so does everyone else. You do it for the shiney badge.so quit complaining
 
Posted January 20, 2008 @ 11:26 PM by Joey
This is so typical for WJHL and BHC. If real news was sitting right under their nose they could not find it. If anyone watches their news, the lead story may be how hot or cold it is, some over exaggerated road conditions, and then off to the local jail to report who was arrested. Maybe Mr. Foster feels under paid and in turn he decides to embarrass many hard working people in the community that takes care of his sorry tail. How would you feel to make a low salary and post it for millions to see
 
Posted January 20, 2008 @ 10:22 AM by Anonymous
IT IS PUBLIC RECORD. EVERY PENNY SPENT IS PUBLIC RECORD. ANYONE CAN GO TO AN OFFICE AND REQUEST ANY FINANCIAL INFORMATION THEY DESIRE. DO NOT LET THIS PAPER ACT LIKE THEY HAVE DONE SOME FANTASTICAL FEAT. THEY ONLY POSTED WHAT IS ALREADY PUBLIC RECORD! I am not angry it is posted. What angers me is that anyone can get this information for themselves if they want it BECAUSE IT IS PUBLIC RECORD. What cracked me up is "their lawyers standing by to sue." Well,"your money" would pay for the defense.
 
Posted January 17, 2008 @ 11:08 AM by Anonymous
Mr. Foster, I am so glad you feel this massive burden to enlighten the public on where their tax dollars are going. You must have had a miserable childhood. I also hope the next time YOU are caught doing 36mph on the Volunteer Parkway that the obviously underpaid civil servant in which you legally disclosed his salary, chooses to FULLY enforce the civil penalties you are paying him for.
 
Posted January 16, 2008 @ 02:38 PM by bsvia
A Republican slogan years ago to elect Bush came up with "its your money" in referring to goverment funds. I beg to differ,legally the goverment is a separate entity from the individuals who are required by law to pay into it. Try writing a check on the goverments accounts to get "your money" and see if it becomes thier money real quick. Its thier money. Just as it is thier trillions debt for Iraq and not my debt. WE quibble over salaries while we ignore the whale about to devour us whole.
 
Posted January 13, 2008 @ 11:42 AM by Anonymous
I still don't see Washington County Virginia Service Authority salaries. It has one of the highest salary rates, but somehow the paper will not pick up on it. What's the deal?
 
Posted January 10, 2008 @ 03:04 PM by Censored
The information should be public, but the public should have to go through the effort to get it themselves. Publishing them online is for the BHC's gain only. They state "WE ARE NOT making any editorial statements about government workers being overpaid or underpaid." Wow, what great insight from our "REGIONAL" paper. As a government employee the biggest result from this is anger/bitterness because of what somebody else makes who works with them everyday. Way to go on hurting efficiency BHC!
 
 Reaction Page:   1 2 3 4 Next >>